Wednesday, April 27, 2016


It is difficult to define the word “holy” or “sacred.” Philosophers have a hard time clarifying the totality of what this word tries to convey. It certainly has to do something with religion, with God, with the otherness of things, or with the numinous quality of being. In modern life today, however, the word does not have a great appeal. The question is whether the concept behind the word is worth preserving.

In the ancient Near East holiness implied separation. In Akkadian the verb qadashu means to become pure. In Mari a qadishtu was a priestess. In the Hebrew Bible qadosh refers to whatever is set aside for a purpose. The Rabbis, too, understood the word in the same manner. Whereas Lev. 19:2 states, “You shall be holy, for I, the Lord your God, am holy” [qadosh], the SIFRA, a legal commentary on the book of Leviticus, states that this means, “You shall be separate [perushim] (from others or sinful acts).” The opposite of holy is profane, impure and ordinary. 

In traditional Hebrew texts, the term qadosh is applied to various spheres:
a)    Holiness can be applied to people, and especially to the people of Israel: “You shall be holy to me, for I the Lord am holy, and I have set you apart from other peoples to be Mine” (Lev. 20: 26). Priests also are considered holy because they were separated from other individuals in the community (Lev. 21: 6).
b)    Objects can be holy: Thus, all priestly clothing is considered holy (Ex. 28:2,4), because only priests can wear them. 
c)     Time can be set aside as holy:  For example, the Sabbath day is viewed as holy, because it is set aside from all other days as a day of worship and rest (Ex. 20:8).
d)    Places can be considered as sacred: Within the ancient temple of Jerusalem, there was a section designated as “Holy of Holies” where presumably the divine dwelled (Ex. 25: 8). Similarly, a sanctuary is called a miqdash (“sacred place’), for, it has been set aside as a special place of worship.
e)    Occasions can be viewed as holy: In the rabbinic literature, the marriage ceremony is called qiddushin (from the same root as qadosh), since both husband and wife set themselves apart for a unique relationship.
f)      The Israelite God, whose personal name, YHVH, we do not know how to pronounce, is viewed as holy, because He has been set aside for an exclusive worship from all other gods in the universe: “Who is like you, O Lord [YHVH], among the gods; Who is like you, majestic in holiness” (Ex. 15: 11). Similarly, in the temple of Jerusalem the prophet Isaiah proclaimed, “Holy, holy, holy, is the Lord of Hosts” (Isa. 6: 3).  

In the Biblical view, holiness is regarded as being gradual from the most sacred to the least sacred; as one gets closer to God, it becomes more holy.  Some individuals, for example, are holier than others. Thus, the High priest is the most sacred; then come the ordinary priests, then the Levites, and finally the Israelites and the resident aliens. Foreign nations appear at the very bottom. In the same vein, when it comes to places, after the “Holy of Holies” in the temple of Jerusalem, you have the temple compound, then the city of Jerusalem, then the Land of Israel, and finally, the least sacred are all other lands outside of Israel. 

            How was God’s holiness understood? Primarily by way of copying divine deeds. For instance, when Lev. 19: 2 states, “You [meaning, the Israelites] shall be holy, because, I, the Lord your God, am holy,” the SIFRA adds that the proper meaning is: “If you sanctify yourselves, then I [God] would consider as if you have sanctified me.” Similarly, Nahmanides (Girona, Spain, b.1194-1270, Israel) comments on the same verse saying, “That means, by being holy we can cling to God”.  In other words, holiness is based on imitatio dei, acting as God would: i.e., If you act in a godly matter, then, God is sanctified. 

The comments above reflect a theistic view of God where God appears as a Person who knows, responds and reacts to human activity. How can holiness be construed within a non-theistic, religious naturalistic point of view (My approach)? I believe that the Biblical concept of “holy” as referring to something that is separate and being set aside for a special purpose is still valid. However, I would argue that nothing is intrinsically sacred. Holiness is a quality that we bestow upon others because we consider them as special, such as historical sites (e.g., the city of Jerusalem, my synagogue in Needham, MA), human relationships (e.g. spouses, parents), the environment (e.g. respect for nature).  [You create your own list].  As to God, which in a non-theistic religious naturalism stands for the energy that animates the universe, divine holiness is based on the life-affirming qualities that we, humans, attribute to all existence that surrounds us, for without that energy we would not exist.
I agree with Michael Benedict who wrote:
“Nothing is holy expect that we sanctify it;
and thus everything is potentially holy
      except cruelty, disease, and untimely death.” (1)

To life!
Rabbi Rifat Sonsino, Ph.D.
April 2016

1.    Michael Benedikt, God is the Good We Do. Botting Books, NY, 2007, 10.

Monday, April 11, 2016


On Friday night, April 8, 2016, my Temple Beth Shalom, Needham, MA (where I am the Emeritus) celebrated my 50th year in the rabbinate with a special Sabbath service. In my response to various speeches, I shared with the congregation the following words:

I have had two major existential crises in my life. The first one occurred when I was in high School in Istanbul, Turkey. I must have been in my early teens when I realized that I was not growing taller. When I complained about it to my French teacher, she, a little old lady that she was, told me, “You measure height from the shoulders up.” That was a revelation to me. From her words I derived the lesson that if I wanted to be successful in life I needed to develop my mind. So, I committed myself to my studies and did very well in High School. In fact, I became the valedictorian of my class.

The second crisis happened in law school (again in Istanbul) when I realized that I wanted to do something else than practicing business law. What shall I do? I was very much influenced by my father who was a good Hebraist and an accomplished structural engineer. I was not good at math. My brother, on the other hand, was the brain of the family, and not surprisingly he became an electrical engineer.  I was good at humanities, and needed to find an avenue for myself. So, with the help of a neighbor who was a liberal Rabbi, my mother’s unswerving love and my father’s passion for Jewish studies, I decided to become a Reform Rabbi in the USA, even though I grew up in an Orthodox Jewish environment. I must been a rebel even then.

I entered the Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion (Cincinnati, Ohio) in 1961 with a great enthusiasm for my newly elected profession. Looking back, I must say that I have been very fortunate. I took a few calculated risks in life. I married a wonderful woman, Ines; I carefully chose the University of Pennsylvania for my graduate school; was thrilled when I became the father of two wonderful children, Daniel and Deborah, and am now grateful to have four grandchildren, Ariella and Dalia, Avi and Talya, who fill me with joy. I was particularly happy to become the Rabbi of great synagogues, first in Buenos Aires, then in Glencoe, Ill, and finally at Beth Shalom, in Needham, MA (suburb of Boston) where I spent 23 productive years of my life. It was in Needham that I really learned how to become a Rabbi in the full sense of the word. Through the help of many of my wonderful past presidents, I was able to put Beth Shalom on the national map, and made sure that Jewish knowledge was based on solid foundation and liberal thinking. I am now thrilled to see the growth of our temple under the rabbinic leadership of Rabbis Perlman and Markley. I can’t wait to see our new building (now under construction) in the Fall of 2016.

Now that I am 77 years old, I have short-term projects. I am looking forward to Ariella’s confirmation this coming June, Avi’s Bar Mitzvah next April, 2017, Dalia’s Bat Mitzvah in Feb. of 2018, and then Talya’s Bat Mitzvah…she is still 8 years old and we don’t have a date yet. I also plan to continue to teach at Framingham State University. It gets me out of the house (Ines is happy about it) and allows me to do what I love best, namely, teaching. Personally, I am now looking at age 80. If I live to be that old, I will set up further short-term projects.

In the meantime, I enjoy the life Ines and I have together, love spending time with my grandchildren here in the Boston area, playing soccer with Avi and acting as a student in Talya’s imaginative class.
I enjoy studying with my rabbinic colleagues on Monday morning, helping my adopted synagogue in Barcelona, Spain, as well as writing, blogging, lecturing and teaching at different places, and doing some traveling to interesting places around the world.

Life is a journey, taken step by step. And I have been among the luckiest people in the world who has had the opportunity to do what I love best.

Rabbi Rifat Sonsino, Ph.D.
April 11, 2016

Sunday, March 20, 2016


On Saturday night, March 12, Bet Shalom congregation of Barcelona celebrated its 10th anniversary with the dedication of a new sanctuary. 

Bet Shalom is an emerging liberal synagogue that is affiliated with the European Union for Progressive Judaism (EUPJ). It has been my privilege to work with them for many years, and to witness their steady growth in a country that has a small Jewish community but a glorious past history in the Jewish world. For many, it is almost a “mother country.” 

My wife and I went to Barcelona first in June, 2008, and worked with Bet Shalom’s lay leadership to give shape to a new movement. A few Rabbis preceded our arrival, each one spending a limited time in the country. The Jewish community in Barcelona is small. Presently, in addition to Bet Shalom, there is an Orthodox Jewish center, a Chabad group and another small progressive synagogue called Atid. I see Bet Shalom as a dynamic, forward thinking, and community oriented. Jai [pronounced as Hai) Anguita, the President, is its indefatigable lay leader, and Maria Prieto Manzanares functions as its representative vis-a-vis the world Jewish community. About 60-70 families are now associated with it.

Since 2008, we have traveled to Barcelona a number of times, and stayed there short periods of time leading services, teaching classes, and giving public lectures on Judaism. I have also done a few weddings, and participated in many rabbinic courts (with Rabbis coming from London) regarding conversions, and I always returned to the States more energized and hopeful for the future. The congregation is now fortunate to have Rabbi Stephen Berkowitz, a graduate of the Reconstructionist seminary, as its religious leader, who from now on will be able to spend a few weeks at a time working with different branches of the congregation. 

The new and spacious sanctuary is located in the area called Gracia, not too far away from the famous Sagrada Familia, the church that was designed by Antoni Gaudi (1852-1936) but still not finished. The celebration attracted many local dignitaries, representatives of other Jewish institutions and Mrs. Miriam Kramer, the Chairperson of EUPJ who came from London. After Havdalah and dedication, which Rabbi Berkowitz and I conducted in Spanish, the congregation and guests, numbering in over 100 people, enjoyed a lovely meal and danced for many hours. They now have a new pulpit and are in the process of getting a new ark that will house the single Torah I brought to them a few years ago. During the rest of the week, I also taught a class on Jewish God concepts to the participants of Introduction to Judaism class, and gave a public lecture on the Expulsion of Jews from Spain in 1492. Spain in now granting citizenship to anyone who can prove a link to the Jewish community that was expelled in the past.

I am very proud of my association with Beth Shalom and hope that with local and international help, it will continue to grow in number and stature, even encouraging others to follow its steady path. Already a few progressive groups are functioning in Madrid and other cities, and look to Bet Shalom for guidance. Spain is emerging again as a new Jewish light. I only hope they go from strength to strength.

Rabbi Rifat Sonsino, Ph.D.
March, 2016