WHERE DOES GOD LIVE?

 Rabbi Rifat Sonsino, Ph.D

Among those who conceive of God in theistic terms, namely as a father image who is all powerful and all-good, there seems to have a universal assumption that God lives in the heavens above.

Here are a few examples:

In one of the most popular Israeli songs today, Tefilah, the singer Omer Adam, invokes God as being  the Only one, and, in the video, he points to the heavens as the place where God can ben found. Similarly, in the Prayer for the State of Israel, the singer invokes God as the one who is avinu she-bashamayim. “Our Father in Heaven.” This is a popular rabbinic expression, even though the concept is already found in the Hebrew Bible (e.g. Isa. 63:16).  

The idea of a heavenly God originated in the Ancient Near East. According to the Sumerian Deluge myth, this event took place “after ...kingship had been lowered from heaven” (where gods live)( ANET, p. 43). Similarly, we are told that ANU, “the father of the gods, lived in the highest level of the heavens” (Horowitz , Mesopotamian Cosmic Geography, 2001:8-11).

The picture in the Hebrew Bible is not clear. At times, we are told that God is  found in a specific place. For example, according to Deut. 33:2, God lives on Mt. Sinai. According to I K 8: 13, God dwells in the Temple built by King Solomon. In Ps. 74:2, God lives in Zion, namely ,Jerusalem. God can also reveal himself out of a burning bush (Ex. 3:4), or even through a  “still small voice” (meaning unclear, I K 19: 12). On the other hand, according to other biblical passages God is everywhere: “If I ascend to heaven, you are there; If I descend to Sheol (underworld), you are there too” (Ps. 139: 7).

The Hebrew word shamayim, (“ heavens”) often refers to the abode of God: In Deuteronomy, God is called the one  who “rides through the heavens” (33:26). In Genesis, God rained upon Sodom and Gomorrah sulfurous fire “from the Lord out of heaven” (19:24). According to the prophet Isaiah, “The heaven is My throne”(66:1). (For more examples, see BDB, p. 1030 , under shamayim).

This assumption is also present in the Christian tradition, where, in the Lord’s Prayer, a worshiper refers to God as “Our Father in Heaven” (Math. 6: 9-13; Luke 11: 2-4).

 On the other hand, religious naturalists or pantheists like Spinoza, Kaplan or Gittelsohn (and me, as one of the followers) who view God as the power or energy behind the universe, maintain that God is omnipresent, and is not limited to the heavens above. In fact, Spinoza equates God with nature, as the only substance there is.

So, you have a choice, and do not assume that theism is the only answer.

SONSINO’S BLOG, rsonsino.blogspot.com